|
|
SOMALILANDHORTA
|
|
Tourists In Somaliland
July 31, 2008 - By Peter Buttigieg and Nathaniel Myers
Last week we went to Somalia as American tourists. We stayed only a night, but
that was plenty of time to wander unescorted through the local market, explore
town in a battered Toyota station wagon, and even head out into the desert to
admire some ancient cave paintings.
It might seem an odd choice of vacation spot, given that Somalia, so long
synonymous with 'failed state,' appears to be growing ever more dangerous. The
insurgency against the American-backed Ethiopian occupation persists, and just
last week it was reported that a particularly radical group has launched a
campaign to murder relief workers, who are there trying desperately to avert an
oncoming famine.
Indeed, we were able to travel safely to Somalia only because of a peculiar but
important technicality: The world makes no distinction between the Republic of
Somaliland, the autonomous and self-governing territory that we visited, and the
rest of Somalia to its south.
Since declaring independence in 1991, Somaliland has achieved a level of peace
and stability beyond the wildest dreams of the quasi-government in Mogadishu.
Yet remarkably, throughout the many years the international community has
funded, fed and sought vainly to stabilize Somalia, it has studiously ignored
the peaceful and democratic polity to Somalia's north.
This is not an oversight but a conscious policy decision: No country on earth
will recognize Somaliland as a peer. The African Union has occasionally
'studied' the issue, but its members are loath to endorse what would amount to
secession from one of their own.
The United States and many European states have said they will defer to the
African Union's policy - despite their willingness last year to proactively
promote the controversial independence of Kosovo.
With the world averting its eyes, the remarkable achievements of Somaliland have
gone unnoticed. In one of the world's most dangerous and unstable areas, it has
managed to establish peace and stability, and gone on to develop a unique
democratic regime that incorporates both direct elections and formal roles for
traditional clan elders. It has established a legal system that carefully
balances local tribal custom, Islamic jurisprudence, and Western constitutional
tradition. While democracy's reputation is precarious throughout much of the
Muslim world, this devout country has held elections on its own initiative and
at considerable cost to its national reserves.
The international community's approach to Somaliland not only ignores these
accomplishments; it might actually destroy them.
Without formal recognition, Somaliland cannot enter into trade agreements with
other countries, and is unable to exploit the natural resources under its earth
and its Red Sea port of Berbera. It struggles to attract foreign investors
willing to operate in an 'ungoverned' area. It can't even receive normal
development aid from donor countries and agencies, because they cannot channel
aid through an unrecognized government. Instead, the people of Somaliland
receive only a portion of the aid designated for 'Somalia.'
The situation has left Somaliland underdeveloped and desperately poor, with the
government often unable to provide even the most basic public services. Of no
less concern, the durability of its democracy has recently come into question,
with scheduled presidential elections delayed until next March. (The official
explanation was that the authorities in this nation of nomadic goat herders
needed more time to register voters.)
It's hard to know which is more improbable: that an impoverished country in a
chaotic but strategically important region would develop its own fragile
democracy, or that the United States would deliberately ignore its requests for
assistance.
In the absence of Western political and economic engagement, Somaliland is
pursuing investment and support from China and Gulf countries. Such support
might be enough to ensure Somaliland's survival and eventual growth, but it will
crowd out America's chance to win the gratitude of a potentially valuable ally
in a very troubled area.
From the journalist who took us to lunch to the guide who took us to the cave
paintings, the people we met in Somaliland were welcoming, hopeful and
bewildered by the absence of recognition from the West. They were frustrated to
still be overlooked out of respect for the sovereignty of the failed state to
their south.
'Every member of Parliament in Mogadishu gets a salary paid mostly by U.S. and
EU funds,' one Somaliland official told us. 'And every one of them is a killer.
If you kill enough people, you are called a warlord and you get invited to
conferences. Meanwhile, I was elected by thousands of votes in a free election,
but the international community does not consider us a country. They should be
rewarding democracy, not killing.'
Copyright @ 2006 Somalilandhorta. All rights
reserved.
For problems or questions regarding this web contact
[Webmaster].
| |
|
|
|